One of the many VAR decisions at the London Stadium
One of the many VAR decisions at the London Stadium

VAR in the Premier League: Former footballers react to first use of Video Assistant Referee system


The Premier League welcomed the Video Assistant Referee system on its opening weekend, with the new technology providing several talking points.

Manchester City were 2-0 up against West Ham at the London Stadium and thought they had a third in the second half, only for Mike Dean to rule Gabriel Jesus' goal out for an offside infringement by Raheem Sterling.

Later in the game West Ham were on the receiving end of VAR however when Sergio Aguero was ordered to retake his missed penalty after encroachment from West Ham's Declan Rice - the Argentinian scored at the second time of asking.

Much of the backlash against VAR in this game appeared to be prompted by the fact Sterling was offside by a matter of millimetres, leading some to question whether the laws of the game needed to be changed.

Three goals were ruled out in total by VAR and over 70 checks were made on decisions over the weekend. It will no doubt take some time to adapt.

We take a look at some of the reaction to its introduction...


The technology had a high-profile supporter, with former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher:


Sterling shoulders the burden of first call:


Former England forward Stan Collymore was irritated by some fan reaction meanwhile, tweeting:


Former England midfielder Danny Murphy wants VAR to be scrapped.

"Something doesn't feel right at the moment when we're watching football," Murphy told talkSPORT.

"I know the majority of what VAR did at the weekend was good - corrected some decisions that would not have been - but if you gave me the choice I'd knock VAR on the head.

"I agree with the Wolves manager (Nuno Espirito Santo). Two minutes celebrating, then you take away that joy. Then the other fans are celebrating a non-goal."

LISTEN: Our football team run through the latest news, views and incidents from the Premier League
LISTEN: Our football team run through the latest news, views and incidents from the Premier League

Murphy was also critical of City having a goal disallowed: "Do we really want to see goals disallowed for an offside that's an armpit ahead of another armpit by four millimetres?

"He might be offside by four millimetres by the letter of the law. But it's an entertainment business, isn't it?

"The Sterling goal that was allowed later, there was muted celebrations.

"You could see he was thinking 'Is this going to get taken away?' and the Man City fans were clapping. It was like applause at the end of the ballet!"


Match of the Day presenter Gary Lineker described himself as "pro VAR" on social media:


Deal with it, is basically what former Man United defender and current England Women boss Phil Neville says:


VAR rules out a Wolves goal against Leicester in their Premier League game
VAR rules out a Wolves goal against Leicester in their Premier League game

"We're going to have to play with our hands chopped off" - So said Wolves captain Conor Coady, who was far from impressed after VAR denied his side a winner at Leicester.

Leander Dendoncker fired home after his initial header struck the arm of team-mate Willy Boly, whose back was turned, at point-blank range. As with offside, there are no grey areas here - any touch with the hand which leads to a goal being scored will be penalised under the new handball law.

"If that is not a goal, there is a problem," a frustrated Coady said after the game.

"They have brought VAR in to rectify all those problems but I think it has gone too far the other way now."


'It's vital', says former referee Dermot Gallagher:


Former City striker Shaun Goater joked about the scoreline, tweeting: "Did @ManCity win 5-0 or we waiting on VAR?" while another former City player David Brightwell said: "It's going to be a looooonnnngggg season watching this farce."


Major League Soccer became one of the first leagues to use a video review system in 2017. Former USA player Alexi Lalas jokingly tweeted: "Welcome to the #VAR party @premierleague."



With the entire Premier League season to come, this will be far from the last time VAR steals the spotlight.

Follow Sporting Life on social media - find us on Facebook here or tweet @SportingLifeFC

Related football links

Like what you've read?

MOST READ FOOTBALL

Sporting Life
Join for free!
Access to exclusive features all for FREE - No monthly subscription fee
Race Replays
My stable horse tracker
giftOffers and prize draws
newsExclusive content

FOOTBALL TIPS